Managing SEO for a single website is challenging enough, but when dealing with multiple websites, the complexity increases exponentially. Multi-site SEO requires a strategic approach to ensure all websites rank well, avoid cannibalization, and drive maximum traffic.
In this case study, we’ll walk you through how we successfully optimized SEO for a multi-site setup, the challenges we faced, and the strategies that helped us achieve top rankings and significant traffic growth.
Also Read: Ready for 2025? Marketing strategies and consumer insights to help you unlock ROI with AI
Background: The Multi-Site SEO Challenge
Our client, a leading e-commerce and service-based company, owned and managed five separate websites catering to different regions and product categories. While each site had unique offerings, there was significant overlap in keywords, content themes, and audience targeting.
The key SEO challenges included:
- Keyword Cannibalization: Multiple websites competing for the same keywords, leading to ranking drops.
- Duplicate Content Issues: Similar products and services causing Google to filter pages as duplicates.
- Technical SEO Complexity: Managing structured data, XML sitemaps, canonical tags, and site speed for multiple domains.
- Backlink Dilution: Multiple domains competing for authority instead of consolidating SEO strength.
- Regional Targeting Issues: Ensuring the correct site ranked in the appropriate geographic location.
Step 1: SEO Audit and Competitive Analysis
Before implementing any changes, we conducted a comprehensive SEO audit for each site to identify weaknesses and opportunities.
Our audit focused on:
- On-Page SEO: Meta tags, headings, internal linking, keyword targeting.
- Technical SEO: Site speed, mobile-friendliness, indexing issues, schema markup.
- Content Strategy: Identifying duplicate content, thin content, and keyword overlap.
- Backlink Profile: Checking link authority, spammy links, and brand mentions.
- Competitor Analysis: Evaluating competitors’ SEO tactics to identify gaps and improvement areas.
Key Findings:
✅ Significant keyword overlap was causing cannibalization.
✅ Duplicate meta tags and product descriptions across sites.
✅ Slow page load times on mobile, affecting rankings.
✅ Weak backlink profile with diluted domain authority.
Step 2: Keyword Segmentation and Content Strategy
To prevent keyword cannibalization and improve organic reach, we created a keyword segmentation strategy:
Assigned Unique Keyword Themes to each website.
- Website A focused on premium products.
- Website B targeted budget-friendly solutions.
- Website C specialized in regional services.
Created a Master Keyword Mapping Sheet
- Mapped high-priority keywords to specific sites.
- Ensured that no two websites targeted the same primary keyword.
Implemented a Content Differentiation Strategy
- Rewrote product descriptions to be unique for each website.
- Developed long-form blog content targeting different customer intent per site.
- Used regional content for localized sites to improve geo-relevance.
Step 3: Technical SEO Fixes
Technical SEO was critical in ensuring that each website was indexed correctly and ranked in its target location.
Here’s how we optimized the technical aspects:
1. Canonical Tags & hreflang Implementation
- Used canonical tags to tell Google which version of similar content should be indexed.
- Implemented hreflang tags to ensure regional sites ranked in their respective countries.
2. Optimized XML Sitemaps and Robots.txt
- Created separate XML sitemaps for each website and submitted them to Google Search Console.
- Updated robots.txt to prevent unnecessary pages from being indexed.
3. Improved Site Speed & Core Web Vitals
- Optimized images and lazy-loaded assets.
- Used a Content Delivery Network (CDN) to serve global audiences faster.
- Minified CSS, JavaScript, and HTML.
4. Structured Data (Schema Markup) Implementation
- Added Product Schema for e-commerce sites to enhance search results.
- Implemented Local Business Schema for regional sites.
- Used FAQ Schema on blog content to improve visibility in Google’s SERP.
Step 4: Backlink Strategy & Domain Authority Consolidation
One of the major challenges in multi-site SEO is link dilution, where backlinks are spread across multiple domains, weakening overall authority.
How We Built a Strong Backlink Profile:
Consolidated Content Where Possible
- Merged similar blog posts across sites into one authoritative piece, linking back to relevant sites.
Implemented a Strategic Internal Linking Plan
- Linked websites together where relevant, ensuring a natural, non-spammy link structure.
Earned High-Quality Backlinks
- Focused on guest posting, HARO (Help a Reporter Out), and industry partnerships to gain authoritative backlinks.
- Ensured each domain received relevant backlinks rather than competing for the same links.
Leveraged Local Citations for Regional SEO
- Created Google My Business listings for each regional site.
- Built NAP (Name, Address, Phone Number) consistency across directories.
Step 5: Monitoring, Testing, and Ongoing Optimization
SEO is an ongoing process, so we continuously monitored and refined our approach.
Key Performance Metrics We Tracked:
✅ Organic Traffic Growth for each website.
✅ Keyword Rankings to ensure proper segmentation.
✅ Bounce Rate & Engagement Metrics to assess content effectiveness.
✅ Backlink Growth and domain authority improvements.
✅ Mobile Performance for Core Web Vitals improvements.
Results After 6 Months:
📈 45% increase in organic traffic across all sites.
📈 35% growth in domain authority through strategic backlinks.
📈 Eliminated keyword cannibalization, leading to stable rankings.
📈 Higher local visibility in Google for region-specific sites.
Lessons Learned & Final Takeaways
🔹 Keyword segmentation is crucial for multi-site SEO success.
🔹 Unique, high-quality content prevents duplicate content penalties.
🔹 Technical SEO must be fine-tuned for proper indexing and regional targeting.
🔹 A strategic backlink approach helps consolidate authority across multiple sites.
By following this structured approach, we successfully mastered multi-site SEO, ensuring each website ranked well without competing against each other.